Best Disability Insurance
for Physicians
We analyzed the "Big 5" carriers that write over 90% of physician policies. Here is the definitive breakdown for 2026.
At a Glance: The "Big 5"
Guardian Life
(Berkshire)The Good
- Strongest "True Own-Occupation" definition
- Includes specialties in definition
- Unmatched financial strength
Best For
The Bottom Line: Guardian is widely considered the "Rolls Royce" of disability insurance. It is often the most expensive option (by 10-15%), but for procedural specialists, the contract language is unbeatable. If you are a surgeon, this should be your first quote.
Principal
The Good
- Excellent value and pricing
- Strong "Benefit Update" rider
- Fewer limitations for mental/nervous
Best For
The Bottom Line: Principal is often the "sweet spot" for many physicians—excellent coverage at a price lower than Guardian. Their contract is very physician-friendly, though proceduralists should compare the specific language carefully against Guardian.
MassMutual
The Good
- Mutual company (policyholders own it)
- Financially incredibly stable
- Great catastrophic disability riders
Best For
The Bottom Line: A solid choice if you value stability above all else. MassMutual is stricter with underwriting, so it can be harder to qualify, but if you do, their policies are rock solid.
The Standard
The Good
- Good pricing tiers for different specialties
- often has discounts for specific hospitals
Best For
The Bottom Line: The Standard typically shines for non-surgical specialties where premium cost is a major factor. They have a solid contract but fewer of the "bells and whistles" of Guardian.
Ameritas
The Good
- Incredible "Future Increase" options
- Aggressive pricing for residents
- Excellent COLA riders
Best For
The Bottom Line: The sleeper hit of the group. For residents looking to lock in a cheap rate with the ability to increase it significantly later without medical underwriting, Ameritas is often the winner.
Join 15,000+ Smart Physicians
Get distinct financial strategies, tax loopholes, and contract negotiation tips delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, ever.
Join 15,000+ physicians. Unsubscribe anytime.