We may earn a commission if you originate a policy through our links — this does not affect our ratings or recommendations. Full disclosure →
Best Medical Malpractice
Insurance 2026
Protect your license and your livelihood. We compared the carriers with the strongest financials, best claims defense, and most comprehensive coverage. Whether you are taking out a practice loan to start your own clinic or joining a large hospital system, malpractice insurance is your first line of defense.
Carrier Comparison Table
Ratings and policy features current as of June 2026. Premiums vary heavily by specialty, claims history, and state.
| Carrier | Best For | A.M. Best Rating | Focus | Pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Doctors Company | All Specialties | A | Physician-Owned | $$ |
| MedPro Group | Risk Averse | A++ | Berkshire Hathaway | $$$ |
| ProAssurance | Education Focused | A | Risk Management | $$ |
| Coverys | Large Groups | A | Data Driven | $$ |
| Cunningham Group | Price Shopping | N/A | Shop the Market | $ |
The Doctors Company
(TDC Group)The Good
- "Tribute Plan" rewards loyal members with financial benefits upon retirement
- Aggressive claims defense (80% of claims closed without payment)
- Owned by its members, so profits return to you via dividends
The Bad
- Not always the absolute lowest premium available
- Underwriting can be strict for physicians with prior claims
- Tribute Plan requires long-term commitment to fully vest
The Bottom Line: It's hard to beat TDC. They have the size, the history, and the physician-centric mission. If they write in your state, you should absolutely get a quote. Their defense is legendary for refusing to settle frivolous claims.
“I was sued for a known complication that the patient was fully consented for. TDC didn't even hesitate; they fought it in court and won. They never pressured me to settle just to save themselves legal fees.”
— Dr. Robert C., General Surgery
How we scored 5/5
TDC scores 5.0 for their physician-first approach, massive financial reserves, and the Tribute Plan which essentially pays you back for years of good practice.
MedPro Group
(Berkshire Hathaway)The Good
- Rated A++ (Superior) by A.M. Best - unmatched financial backing
- Oldest healthcare liability carrier in the nation (since 1899)
- Offers "Pure Consent" options (no hammer clause)
The Bad
- Often the most expensive option on the market
- Less focus on returning profits to physicians compared to mutuals
- Can be overly conservative in underwriting
The Bottom Line: If you want the peace of mind that comes from knowing your insurer has the deepest pockets in the world (thank you, Warren Buffett), MedPro is the choice. They simply do not lose sleep over massive payouts.
“In OB/GYN, the liability tails are measured in decades. I chose MedPro because I know without a doubt they will still be financially solvent 20 years from now if a claim arises from a past delivery.”
— Dr. Anita M., OB/GYN
How we scored 4.9/5
MedPro scores 4.9 for being the absolute gold standard in financial stability. When you are insuring against multi-million dollar judgements, solvency is everything.
ProAssurance
The Good
- Known for their "Treated Fairly" pledge and transparency
- Huge library of risk management seminars (for CME credit)
- Strong regional presence in the South and Midwest
The Bad
- Financial ratings are strong but lag behind MedPro
- Premiums can spike significantly after a claim
- Not available in every single state
The Bottom Line: ProAssurance treats you like a partner, not a policy number. Their focus on helping you avoid claims in the first place through robust education is invaluable for solo practitioners.
“Their risk management seminars are actually incredibly useful, not just a box to check. Applying their advice lowered my premiums by 10% this year.”
— Dr. James P., Family Medicine
How we scored 4.7/5
ProAssurance scores 4.7 for their unmatched commitment to proactive risk management and transparent claims handling.
Coverys
The Good
- Uses advanced data analytics to identify risk patterns
- "Active Risk Management" helps you improve outcomes
- Excellent business intelligence reports for practice managers
The Bad
- Can feel overly corporate for solo practitioners
- Data reporting requirements can be burdensome
- Customer service is geared more toward hospital administrators
The Bottom Line: Coverys is the smart choice for larger groups or health systems that want to use big data to drive down their risk profile (and eventually their aggregate premiums).
“As a practice manager for a 40-physician group, Coverys provides me with incredible dashboards showing exactly where our liability vulnerabilities lie, mostly in our follow-up protocols.”
— Sarah L., Practice Administrator
How we scored 4.7/5
Coverys scores 4.7 for pioneering the use of predictive analytics in medical malpractice, making them the best choice for institutional clients.
Cunningham Group
(Independent Broker)The Good
- Independent Agency - they work for you, not the carrier
- Can quote from almost every major carrier in your state
- Provides free "Malpractice Policy Audit" services
The Bad
- They are a broker, so they do not actually underwrite the policy
- You will eventually deal with the chosen carrier for claims
- Some exclusive mutuals may not work through all outside brokers
The Bottom Line: If you are unsure which carrier is best for you, start here. They will pull quotes from everyone (including many on this list) and present you with a side-by-side comparison to find the best value.
“I had no idea where to start when opening my direct primary care practice. Cunningham took my info once and came back with 6 different quotes, saving me hours of paperwork.”
— Dr. Emily R., Direct Primary Care
How we scored 4.8/5
Cunningham Group scores 4.8 for providing an essential service: transparency. They are the easiest way to ensure you aren't overpaying for your liability coverage.
Jump to Carrier
The "Tail" Trap
Understanding the true cost of Claims-Made policies.
Cost of Tail: Typically 1.5x to 2.5x your final year's annual premium, due in one lump sum.
Tip: Always negotiate for your employer to pay for your tail coverage in your initial employment contract!
High-Risk Specialties
OB/GYN, Neurosurgery, and General Surgery consistently face the highest malpractice premiums and claim frequencies. If you are in these fields, prioritize carriers with the strongest financial reserves (A++ A.M. Best) over the cheapest monthly premium. And don't forget to protect your income with True Own-Occupation Disability Insurance.
Verify Your Coverage Limits
Most states require minimum coverage limits (e.g., $1M per occurrence / $3M aggregate). However, in states with caps on non-economic damages, these standard limits are usually sufficient. In states without caps, many physicians opt for higher limits or supplemental umbrellas. Always consult with a local healthcare attorney or specialized broker to determine the appropriate limits for your specific location and specialty.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Claims-Made and Occurrence policies?
An Occurrence policy covers you for any incident that occurs during the policy period, regardless of when the claim is filed. A Claims-Made policy only covers you if the incident occurred AND the claim is filed while the policy is active. Claims-Made policies are cheaper initially but require you to buy "Tail" coverage if you leave or retire to cover future claims.
What is a Consent-to-Settle clause?
A pure consent-to-settle clause means the insurance company cannot settle a malpractice claim without your written permission. This is critical because a settlement goes on your permanent National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) record. Some policies have a "hammer clause" which states if you refuse to settle, you are personally liable for any court judgement above the proposed settlement amount.
Should I buy my own policy if my hospital covers me?
Many employed physicians rely entirely on their hospital’s malpractice coverage. However, if the hospital’s limits are shared among many defendants, or if you are sued after leaving the hospital, you might be exposed. Some physicians purchase a supplemental "nose" or personal policy for extra peace of mind, though it is usually unnecessary if your employer provides adequate occurrence or claims-made-with-tail coverage.
Disclaimer: Policy availability, features, and pricing are current as of June 2026 and are subject to change. This page contains affiliate links — MedMoneyGuide may earn a commission if you originate a policy through our links. This does not influence our ratings, which are based on independent analysis of each carrier's financial strength and defense history. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or legal advice.
The Financial Newsletter Built for Physicians
Get distinct financial strategies, tax loopholes, and contract negotiation tips delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, ever.
Free. Physician-focused. Unsubscribe anytime.
Editorial Credibility
J.R. Dunigan, DO | Family Medicine Physician & Founder
I founded MedMoneyGuide to provide physicians with unbiased, specialty-specific financial guidance. My goal is to add transparency and credibility to your financial journey.