Skip to content

Pension Lump Sum or Annuity? A Decision Guide for Physicians (2026)

How plans price the lump sum, what the pension is really worth, what happens if your hospital is in trouble, and the tax traps in between.

Joshua Dunigan, DO
EDITOR-IN-CHIEFJoshua Dunigan, DO
Sources cited
Updated November 2026

Key takeaways

  • The monthly pension is longevity insurance: a $1,000,000 lump sum must earn 5.9% a year to match $7,000 a month to 85, and 7.1% to 90.
  • Rising interest rates shrink the lump sum; the monthly pension doesn't change.
  • The PBGC insures private plans up to $7,789.77 a month at 65 in 2026, but church plans at many religious hospitals aren't insured.
  • Take a lump sum as a direct rollover to avoid 20% withholding.
Your next steps
You're researching investing and tax strategy.
Your likely goal: capture the match and open Roth space while your tax rate is low.
Where you are
Your progress on this goal
Step 1 of 4
LearnRun numbersCompareAct
Recommended, in order
Roth IRA, budgeting, and what to do first on a resident salary.
Guide
Model a late start and high catch-up potential.
Calculator
Execute it correctly — the most commonly botched step.
Calculator
Pick a mix that matches your career stage and risk.
Calculator

Pensions are rare in most of American work now, but not in medicine. Hospitals, health systems, Kaiser's medical groups, the VA and the big public university systems still promise physicians a monthly check for life. When you retire or leave, many of those plans ask a question with six or seven figures riding on it: do you want the monthly payments, or a single lump sum now?

Neither choice is right for everyone. You can work out which is right for you, though, from four things: how the plan priced the lump sum, how long you're likely to live, who is standing behind the promise, and what the tax rules do to the money on its way out. This guide walks through each, with a worked example and a calculator for your own offer.


Who actually gets this choice

Whether you can take a lump sum at all depends on the kind of plan. The same word, pension, covers very different promises:

Private hospital or health-system pension
Lump sum?
Often, as an option at retirement or when you leave. Your spouse has to consent in writing to anything other than a joint-and-survivor annuity.
Who stands behind it
The plan trust, then the PBGC up to its limit
Church plan (many religiously affiliated hospitals)
Lump sum?
Depends on the plan document; ERISA's rules may not apply.
Who stands behind it
The plan trust only, unless the plan elected PBGC coverage
Cash balance plan
Lump sum?
Usually: the benefit is stated as an account balance, and paying it out as a lump sum is common.
Who stands behind it
The plan trust, then the PBGC if covered
Kaiser Permanente medical groups
Lump sum?
Varies by medical group and plan; some physician plans offer a lump sum and some pay only monthly. Read your summary plan description.
Who stands behind it
The plan trust, then the PBGC if covered
VA (FERS)
Lump sum?
No. Leave early and you can take a refund of your contributions, which gives up the annuity for that service.
Who stands behind it
The federal government
University of California (UCRP)
Lump sum?
A lump sum cashout for eligible members, in place of all monthly income and retiree health coverage.
Who stands behind it
The University of California
Texas TRS (UT System physicians in TRS)
Lump sum?
A partial lump sum of 12, 24 or 36 months of payments, for members who qualify, in exchange for a smaller monthly benefit for life.
Who stands behind it
The state retirement system

Sources: IRS on joint-and-survivor annuities, the Supreme Court in Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton (2017), OPM on FERS refunds, UC's lump sum cashout fact sheet, TRS's partial lump sum FAQ. Plan terms change; your plan's documents control.

Our guides to the Kaiser physician pension, the VA pension, UC's Pension Choice, the UT System's TRS and ORP and cash balance plans cover each plan's own rules. Two details from the table matter for everyone. UC's cashout, according to UC's fact sheet, replaces everything: monthly income, the survivor benefit and the right to continue retiree health coverage. And in a private plan, if you're married, the default payout is a joint-and-survivor annuity; your spouse must consent in writing, witnessed by a notary or plan representative, before the plan can pay you a lump sum or a single-life annuity instead.


How your plan sets the lump sum

A lump sum is the plan's estimate of what your future monthly payments are worth today. For private plans, federal law sets a floor on that estimate: under section 417(e) of the tax code, the lump sum can't be less than the present value worked out with an IRS mortality table and three IRS interest rates, called segment rates, built from high-quality corporate bond yields. Each payment is discounted at the rate for when it's due: the first segment for payments in the next five years, the second for years 5 to 20, and the third for payments after that.

The direction is what matters: higher rates mean a smaller lump sum for the same pension. The rates rose through the first half of 2026:

January
First segment
4.03%
Second segment
5.20%
Third segment
6.12%
April
First segment
4.27%
Second segment
5.34%
Third segment
6.22%
July
First segment
4.62%
Second segment
5.62%
Third segment
6.51%

Minimum present value segment rates under section 417(e)(3)(D), from IRS Notices 2026-14, 2026-31 and 2026-51 (Internal Revenue Bulletins 2026-11, 2026-23 and 2026-38).

How much does a point of interest move the number? Take a simpler version of the math: $7,000 a month for 25 years, roughly a 65-year-old's payments to 90, without the mortality weighting. At 5% that stream is worth $1,210,783 today; at 6% it's worth $1,103,021, about 9% less. Your plan's actual formula weights each payment by the chance you're alive to collect it, but it moves the same way.

Two practical consequences. First, plans don't reprice every day: many fix the rate for a whole plan year using the rates from a month before it starts. Ask your plan which month it uses, because retiring just before or just after that reset can change the offer by tens of thousands of dollars. Second, the law sets only a floor. Some plans pay more than the minimum, and the plan's benefit election package will state the interest rate and mortality table it used. That number is worth comparing with what an insurer would charge to buy the same monthly income, which you can get as quotes for a single-premium immediate annuity.


What the monthly pension is worth: a worked example

Say a hospitalist retiring at 65 is offered $1,000,000 or $7,000 a month for life, single-life, with no cost-of-living raise. These are round numbers for illustration; your plan's offer will differ.

Break-even. The pension pays $84,000 a year, so it takes 11.9 years, to about age 77, for the checks to add up to the lump sum, before counting any investment return on the lump sum. That's the floor of the comparison, not the answer, because the lump sum would be invested.

The return the lump sum needs. The better question is what the lump sum would have to earn to pay you the same $7,000 a month for as long as you live. That depends on how long that is:

80
Return the lump sum must earn each year
3.2%
85
Return the lump sum must earn each year
5.9%
90
Return the lump sum must earn each year
7.1%
95
Return the lump sum must earn each year
7.8%

To pay $7,000 a month from age 65 until that age with nothing left over, before taxes. Computed with the same code as the calculator below.

For context, the Social Security actuarial table gives a 65-year-old man about 18 more years on average and a 65-year-old woman about 21, which is to roughly 83 and 86. Physicians tend to beat those averages: in a JAMA Internal Medicine study of US deaths in 2020 to 2022 among people 25 to 74, physicians died at about half the rate of other high-income workers (269.3 vs. 499.2 per 100,000, adjusted for age and sex). And an average is just the middle: a fair share of 65-year-olds reach their 90s, which is where the pension pulls far ahead.

Here is the same comparison as a picture. Take the lump sum, invest it at a steady return, and pay yourself the pension amount every month:

Chart: a $1,000,000 lump sum paying $7,000 a month from age 65
4% a year: gone at 816% a year: gone at 857% a year: gone at 89
$0$250,000$500,000$750,000$1,000,00065707580859095
Age 80
At 4% $88,344 left
At 6% $388,175 left
At 7% $581,298 left

At 4% a year the money runs out at about 81, at 6% at about 85, and at 7% at about 89. The pension keeps paying $7,000 a month for life. Steady returns flatter the lump sum: a market drop in the first few years shortens these ages. Before taxes; computed with the calculator's code.

The other side of the ledger is inflation. A pension without a cost-of-living raise pays the same dollars at 85 that it pays at 65. At 3% inflation, $7,000 a month buys what about $3,876 buys today after 20 years. A lump sum invested in stocks can keep up with inflation; a fixed pension can't. That is the strongest argument for the lump sum among healthy physicians with long horizons, and it's why the comparison is closer than the table above makes it look.

Your offer

Lump sum or pension: run your numbers

Break-even age$1,000,000 ÷ $84,000 a year = 11.9 years of payments, before any investment return76.9
Return needed to match it to 85What the lump sum must earn a year to pay $7,000 a month until 855.9%
Return needed to match it to 90What the lump sum must earn a year to pay $7,000 a month until 907.1%
Return needed to match it to 95What the lump sum must earn a year to pay $7,000 a month until 957.8%
Runs out at 4% a yearPaying yourself $7,000 a month from the lump sumAge 81
Runs out at 6% a yearPaying yourself $7,000 a month from the lump sumAge 85
Runs out at 7% a yearPaying yourself $7,000 a month from the lump sumAge 89

Before taxes. Assumes a pension with no cost-of-living raise and no survivor benefit, paid monthly. The returns are steady averages; real markets aren't, and a bad first few years shortens how long the lump sum lasts. The pension pays for as long as you live.


If your hospital is in trouble

This is the question behind a lot of lump sum decisions, especially at health systems that have been through closures or sales. Pension assets sit in a trust, separate from the hospital's own money, so a bankruptcy doesn't hand them to the hospital's creditors. What matters is whether the plan has enough in it, and who pays if it doesn't.

The PBGC guarantee and its limit

If a private single-employer plan ends without enough money, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation takes it over and pays benefits up to a yearly maximum, which is lower for people who start payments younger and lower for survivor forms:

2026
Maximum at 65, single-life
$7,789.77 a month
Per year
$93,477
Joint and 50% survivor at 65
$7,010.79 a month
2027
Maximum at 65, single-life
$8,113.64 a month
Per year
$97,364
Joint and 50% survivor at 65
$7,302.28 a month

PBGC maximum guarantees for single-employer plans, from the PBGC's maximum monthly guarantee tables, the Congressional Research Service PBGC primer (2026) and Mercer's summary of the 2027 figures. Benefit increases adopted in the five years before a plan ends are only partly guaranteed.

In our example, $7,000 a month at 65 sits under both limits, so it would be fully guaranteed if the plan is covered. A physician with a larger pension, or one who starts it at 60, could be above the limit, and the part above it is at risk.

Church plans and government plans aren't PBGC-insured

Many Catholic and other religiously affiliated health systems run their pensions as church plans. In Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton (2017), the Supreme Court held that a plan maintained by a church-affiliated organization can qualify as a church plan even if a church didn't establish it. Church plans can be exempt from ERISA's funding rules and from PBGC premiums, which also means they aren't PBGC-insured unless the plan elected coverage. If your employer is religiously affiliated, the plan's summary plan description or annual notice will say whether the PBGC covers it. If it doesn't, your monthly pension is only as good as the plan's funding, and a shaky employer is a real reason to lean toward the lump sum, if one is offered.

Government plans (the VA, state university systems, teacher systems) aren't PBGC-insured either, but for a different reason: the government that sponsors them stands behind them.

The lump sum can disappear when you need it

For private single-employer plans, section 436 of the tax code restricts lump sums when a plan is underfunded. Below 80% funded, the plan can pay at most half of a lump sum (or the present value of the PBGC guarantee, if less), with the rest as an annuity; below 60%, it can't pay lump sums at all. So the physicians most worried about a struggling plan are the ones most likely to find the lump sum restricted. Your plan's annual funding notice shows its funded percentage for the last three years.

When the plan buys you an insurance annuity

Some employers move retirees' pensions to an insurance company, which then pays the monthly benefit. After that, the PBGC no longer stands behind the payments; the insurer does, backed by your state's guaranty association if the insurer fails. Those associations cover annuities up to a limit on their present value that varies by state, commonly $250,000 or $300,000, which a physician's pension can exceed.

And your 403(b)?

Physicians at struggling hospitals also ask whether to move their 403(b). A 403(b) is held in annuity contracts or custodial accounts in your name, not on the hospital's books, so the hospital's finances don't put it at risk. The exception is a non-governmental 457(b), which legally stays the employer's money until it's paid out.


Taxes and the rollover

The annuity is taxed as ordinary income as you receive it, the same as wages, except for any part that came from after-tax contributions. Private hospital pensions are usually funded by the employer, so for most physicians nearly all of the payment is taxable.

The lump sum is taxable in full in the year you take it, unless you roll it over. Ask the plan for a direct rollover to an IRA or to a new employer's plan, so the money goes straight there and nothing is withheld. If the plan pays you instead, it must withhold 20%, and you have 60 days to deposit the full amount, making up the withheld 20% from other money, or the difference is taxed as income (IRS Publication 575).

The age-55 rule. Withdrawals before 59½ usually cost an extra 10%, but the IRS waives it for withdrawals from an employer plan after you leave that employer in or after the year you turn 55. It doesn't apply to IRAs. A physician who retires at 57 and may need some of the money before 59½ can leave that part in the plan, if it allows partial withdrawals, instead of rolling all of it to an IRA.

Required withdrawals. Rolled into an IRA, the money grows tax-deferred until required minimum distributions start: at 73 for people born from 1951 through 1958, and at 75 for those born in 1960 or later. The pension, by contrast, pays out from the day it starts, which is a reason some physicians with large IRAs prefer to keep the lump sum invested and control the timing of the taxable income themselves.


How to decide

The annuity tends to win when:

  • You're in good health and your parents lived long; the longer you live, the higher the return the lump sum needs.
  • A spouse depends on the income, and a joint-and-survivor annuity covers both of your lifetimes.
  • Your other guaranteed income (Social Security, another pension) wouldn't cover your basic spending, and the pension would.
  • The plan is PBGC-insured or government-backed, and your benefit sits within the guarantee.
  • You know yourself: a market drop would tempt you to sell, or a large balance would tempt you to spend it.

The lump sum tends to win when:

  • Your health is poor or your life expectancy is short.
  • The plan is an uninsured church plan and the employer is struggling.
  • Your basic spending is already covered by other guaranteed income, and the pension money is for flexibility, growth or heirs. An annuity stops at death (or the survivor's death); an invested lump sum can be left to children.
  • The plan priced the lump sum generously compared with what an insurer would charge for the same income.
  • You want inflation protection and are comfortable investing for it.

You don't always have to choose all or nothing. Texas TRS offers a partial lump sum, some plans let you split the benefit, and many physicians keep the pension as their floor of guaranteed income while investing their 401(k), 403(b) and taxable savings for growth. If you're planning around a larger number, our guide to physician net worth at retirement shows how the pieces fit together.


Before you sign the election form

  1. Get the benefit election package and find the interest rate and mortality table behind the lump sum, plus the date the rate resets.
  2. Price the pension yourself with the calculator above, and get a quote for a single-premium immediate annuity paying the same amount.
  3. Read the annual funding notice: the plan's funded percentage and whether the PBGC covers it.
  4. Compare the survivor options (50%, 75%, 100%) with your spouse; their written consent is required for anything else.
  5. Check what else rides on the choice, such as retiree health coverage at UC.
  6. Arrange a direct rollover if you take the lump sum, and keep any money you'll need before 59½ where the age-55 rule applies.
  7. Talk to a fee-only planner if the amount is large. A one-time flat fee is small next to a seven-figure decision; our guide to financial advisors for physicians covers how to find one who isn't paid to sell you an annuity or to manage the lump sum.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I take a lump sum or annuity from a hospital pension?

It depends on four things: how long you expect to live, whether a spouse needs income after you, how safe the plan is, and how much other guaranteed income you'll have. The annuity is longevity insurance: in our example, a $1,000,000 lump sum offered against $7,000 a month at 65 would have to earn about 5.9% a year to keep paying that much to age 85, and about 7.1% to age 90. The lump sum wins when your health is poor, when the plan isn't insured and the employer is shaky, or when you already have enough guaranteed income and want flexibility or something to leave to heirs. Many physicians split the difference by keeping the annuity and investing other savings, or by taking a partial lump sum where the plan allows it.

Does the PBGC insure my hospital pension?

Only if it's a private single-employer plan covered by ERISA's insurance program. Many religiously affiliated hospitals run "church plans," which the Supreme Court confirmed in 2017 can be exempt from ERISA, and those aren't PBGC-insured unless the plan elected coverage. Government plans (VA, state university and teacher systems) aren't PBGC-insured either; they're backed by the government that sponsors them. For a covered plan that ends in 2026, the PBGC guarantees up to $7,789.77 a month for a 65-year-old taking a single-life annuity, rising to $8,113.64 for plans that end in 2027. Your plan's annual funding notice says whether it's covered.

Why did my pension lump sum offer go down?

Almost always because interest rates went up. Private plans convert your pension to a lump sum using IRS interest rates based on corporate bond yields (the 417(e) segment rates), and a higher rate means a smaller lump sum for the same monthly benefit. The first-segment rate rose from 4.03% in January 2026 to 4.62% in July. In a simple version of the math, a one-point rise in rates cuts the value of a $7,000-a-month pension paid to age 90 by about 9%. Many plans set the rate once a year from a month before the plan year starts, so ask which month your plan uses.

Can I roll a pension lump sum into an IRA without paying tax?

Yes, if the plan sends it directly to the IRA or another employer plan (a direct rollover). If the check is made out to you instead, the plan must withhold 20% for taxes, and you have 60 days to deposit the full amount, including the 20% from other money, or the shortfall is taxed. One catch for physicians who retire between 55 and 59½: the rule that waives the 10% early-withdrawal penalty after you leave your employer at 55 or later applies to withdrawals from the employer plan, not from an IRA.

What happens to my pension if my hospital goes bankrupt?

Pension money sits in a trust, separate from the hospital's own assets, so a bankruptcy doesn't let creditors take it. The risk is that the plan is underfunded when it ends. For a PBGC-insured plan, the PBGC takes over and pays benefits up to its limit. For an uninsured church plan, benefits depend on what's in the plan. An underfunded private plan may also be barred from paying lump sums: below 80% funded it can pay at most half of one, and below 60% none at all, so the choice can disappear just when you'd want it.

Sources

  1. Maximum monthly guarantee tables, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  2. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC): A Primer, Congressional Research Service (2026 guarantee limits). Accessed November 18, 2026.
  3. 2027 PBGC premium and maximum guaranteed benefit figures, Mercer, October 2026. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  4. 26 U.S. Code § 417 (minimum present value of lump sums), § 430(h) (segment rates) and § 436 (funding-based limits on benefits), Legal Information Institute. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  5. IRS minimum present value segment rates: Notice 2026-14 in Internal Revenue Bulletin 2026-11, Notice 2026-31 in IRB 2026-23 and Notice 2026-51 in IRB 2026-38. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  6. Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton, 581 U.S. ___ (2017), Legal Information Institute. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  7. Retirement topics: Qualified joint and survivor annuity, IRS. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  8. Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions and Publication 575, Pension and Annuity Income, IRS. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  9. Topic no. 558, Additional tax on early distributions from retirement plans other than IRAs, IRS. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  10. Retirement topics: Required minimum distributions, IRS. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  11. UC Retirement Plan lump sum cashout fact sheet, University of California. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  12. Partial lump-sum option FAQs, Teacher Retirement System of Texas. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  13. FERS information for former employees (refunds and deferred annuities), U.S. Office of Personnel Management. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  14. How you're protected, National Organization of Life & Health Insurance Guaranty Associations. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  15. Actuarial life table, Social Security Administration (period life table used in the 2026 Trustees Report). Accessed November 18, 2026.
  16. Mortality among US physicians and other health care workers, JAMA Internal Medicine, 2025. Accessed November 18, 2026.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and isn't financial, tax, or legal advice. Pension terms vary by plan and change over time; your plan's documents and administrator control. The worked example and calculator are simplified illustrations before taxes, not your plan's actuarial calculation. MedMoneyGuide has no affiliate or advertising relationships with the companies it covers.

Joshua Dunigan, DO

About the Author

Joshua Dunigan, DO | Family Medicine Resident & Founder

I'm a family medicine resident physician in Des Moines, Iowa (class of 2027). I founded MedMoneyGuide to give physicians specialty-specific financial guidance, with sources you can check.