Skip to content

Self-Directed IRAs and Solo 401(k)s for Real Estate: What Physicians Can and Can't Do

A self-directed IRA or solo 401(k) can own a rental property, but the rules are strict: no personal use, no family tenants, no sweat equity, no personal guarantee on the loan, and a tax inside the IRA on income from borrowed money. What the Code, the regulations and the courts allow, why a solo 401(k) handles a mortgage better, and a worked example of the tax.

Joshua Dunigan, DO
EDITOR-IN-CHIEFJoshua Dunigan, DO
Sources cited
Updated November 2026

Key takeaways

  • An IRA or solo 401(k) can own rental real estate. The law doesn't forbid it; many custodians just don't offer it, so you need a self-directed custodian or a plan whose document allows it.
  • The account must deal with the property at arm's length. You, your spouse, parents, children, grandchildren and their spouses, and businesses you control can't live in it, rent it, sell it to the account, lend to it, guarantee its loan or work on it. A violation in an IRA turns the whole account into a taxable distribution as of January 1 of that year.
  • Any loan must be non-recourse. The Tax Court has held that a personal guaranty is a prohibited extension of credit.
  • Borrowed money makes part of the rent and part of the gain taxable inside an IRA as unrelated debt-financed income, at trust rates that reach 37% above $16,000 in 2026. A solo 401(k) is exempt from that tax on real estate debt under section 514(c)(9).
  • In our worked example, a $400,000 rental bought with a $160,000 loan and sold after 10 years costs the IRA about $20,187 in unrelated business income tax, nearly all of it on the sale; the same purchase in a solo 401(k) owes $0. Those figures rest on stated assumptions.
  • Custodians don't vet investments, and regulators warn that self-directed accounts attract fraud.
Your next steps
You're researching investing and tax strategy.
Your likely goal: capture the match and open Roth space while your tax rate is low.
Where you are
Your progress on this goal
Step 1 of 4
LearnRun numbersCompareAct
Recommended, in order
Roth IRA, budgeting, and what to do first on a resident salary.
Guide
Model a late start and high catch-up potential.
Calculator
Execute it correctly — the most commonly botched step.
Calculator
Pick a mix that matches your career stage and risk.
Calculator

The short answer: yes, a physician can buy a rental with a self-directed IRA or a solo 401(k), but it is a narrow path. The property has to be an investment the account owns at arm's length, paid for and financed by the account alone, with no personal use and no help from you or your family beyond making decisions. If you plan to borrow, a solo 401(k) avoids a tax an IRA pays. For most physicians, a REIT fund in an ordinary retirement account, or a rental owned outside the account where depreciation works for you, is simpler and often better.

Our real estate investing guide covers the ways physicians own property and our real estate taxes guide covers depreciation and the passive loss rules outside retirement accounts. This guide covers the retirement-account route. Every rule below links to the Internal Revenue Code, Treasury regulations, IRS publications and forms, or a court opinion. Where a point rests only on custodian practice or practitioner commentary, we say so; where we could not verify a figure (custodian fees and typical non-recourse loan terms), we left it out.


What "Self-Directed" Means

"Self-directed IRA" isn't a legal category. Every IRA is a trust or custodial account held by a bank or another approved trustee (26 U.S.C. 408(a)), and the tax law lets an IRA hold almost anything except life insurance and most collectibles. The IRS puts it plainly: IRA law doesn't prohibit investing in real estate, but trustees aren't required to offer it, and many don't because of the administrative burden (IRS retirement plan investments FAQs). A "self-directed" custodian is simply one that will hold assets such as real estate, private companies, notes and partnership interests.

Two structures

  1. Custodian-held. The IRA holds title to the property in the custodian's name for your benefit. You direct the investment; the custodian signs the purchase documents, receives the rent and pays the bills from the account, transaction by transaction.
  2. IRA-owned LLC ("checkbook IRA"). The IRA buys 100% of a new limited liability company, and you, as the LLC's manager, write checks from the LLC's bank account. It avoids sending each payment through the custodian, and it puts every decision and every payment in your hands, which is exactly where the prohibited transaction risk lives.

The IRS and the courts on checkbook IRAs

No statute, regulation or IRS ruling authorizes the IRA-owned LLC, and none forbids it. The structure rests mainly on Swanson v. Commissioner, 106 T.C. 76 (1996): an IRA bought all the newly issued stock of a company its owner had organized, and the Tax Court held that the stock issuance wasn't a prohibited transaction, because a company with no shares outstanding wasn't yet a "disqualified person." The opinion turned on the IRS's litigation position, and the IRS later told its examiners not to pursue similar cases while warning that similar transactions may still be prohibited on their own facts (IRS Field Service Advice 200128011). In Ellis, the Tax Court likewise found an IRA's purchase of an interest in a new LLC wasn't itself prohibited; the problem was what happened afterward (Ellis v. Commissioner, 8th Cir. 2015).

The IRS treats what the LLC does as what the IRA does. On precious metals, for example, it says that having an IRA-owned LLC buy bullion is an indirect acquisition by the IRA (IRS retirement plans FAQs regarding IRAs), and in McNulty v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. No. 10 (2021), the Tax Court held that coins an IRA-owned LLC bought became taxable distributions when the owner kept them at home; the court found she had complete, unfettered control over them, and accuracy-related penalties applied (opinion). For real estate the lesson is the same: the LLC's property is the IRA's property, and your control over it doesn't make it yours to use.

What a custodian does and doesn't do

A self-directed custodian holds and administers the account's assets, processes your instructions and sends the IRS the year-end account value. According to an investor alert from the SEC, FINRA and the state securities regulators' association (updated in 2023), custodians don't evaluate the quality or legitimacy of any investment or its promoters, don't verify the financial information about it, and using a legitimate custodian doesn't make an investment legitimate (SEC investor alert; NASAA). Custodians also don't police the prohibited transaction rules for you; avoiding them is the account owner's job.


Prohibited Transactions: The Rules That Decide Everything

Section 4975 of the Code applies to IRAs and to qualified plans such as a solo 401(k) (26 U.S.C. 4975(e)(1)). It prohibits any direct or indirect (4975(c)(1)):

  1. sale, exchange or lease of property between the account and a disqualified person;
  2. lending of money or other extension of credit between them;
  3. furnishing of goods, services or facilities between them;
  4. transfer to, or use by or for the benefit of, a disqualified person of the account's income or assets;
  5. act by a fiduciary dealing with the account's income or assets in his own interest; and
  6. receipt of anything by a fiduciary from a party dealing with the account in connection with its transactions.

Good faith doesn't matter, and neither does whether the deal helped the account: the Eighth Circuit applied the rule in Ellis without regard to either (Ellis).

Who is a disqualified person

The list in section 4975(e)(2), as it applies to your own IRA or solo 401(k), includes (4975(e)(2) and (6); IRS Publication 590-A):

  • You, as the fiduciary who directs the account, and for a solo 401(k) also as the employer that sponsors it.
  • Your family as the Code defines it: your spouse, ancestors (parents, grandparents), lineal descendants (children, grandchildren) and the spouses of lineal descendants. Siblings, aunts, uncles, cousins and in-laws other than a child's spouse aren't on the list.
  • Service providers and other fiduciaries to the account, such as an adviser who directs it.
  • Entities 50% or more owned, directly or indirectly, by the people above: your practice, your consulting company, a family LLC.
  • For plans, also officers, directors, 10% shareholders and 10% partners of the employer and of those entities.

Where physicians trip

  1. Using the property. Staying in the condo the IRA owns, even for a weekend, or letting your children use it. The IRS lists buying property for personal use, present or future, with IRA funds as a prohibited transaction (Publication 590-A; 4975(c)(1)(D)). A retirement home bought now for later use falls on the wrong side of that line.
  2. Renting to family or to your practice. A lease between the account and a disqualified person is prohibited (4975(c)(1)(A)), whether the tenant is your daughter or a practice you own half of. Section 4975(d) lists statutory exemptions for specific transactions; check any arrangement with your practice against them with ERISA counsel before relying on one.
  3. Sweat equity. Painting, repairs, renovation labor or managing the property yourself. The statute lists furnishing services between the account and a disqualified person, and IRA contributions must be in cash, not property or labor (Publication 590-A). Custodians and practitioners widely treat an owner's labor as prohibited; we found no court case squarely on unpaid repairs, so this rests on the statute's text and practitioner reading. Decisions are yours to make; the work goes to unrelated contractors paid by the account.
  4. Paying expenses from your own pocket. Covering a property tax bill or a repair personally when the IRA is short of cash. It isn't a permitted way to add money to an IRA (contributions must be cash and are capped at $7,500 a year for 2026 and 2027, $8,600 at 50 and over), and it risks being treated as an extension of credit or a benefit flowing between you and the account. Practitioners treat this as a violation; we found no case squarely on point. Keep enough cash in the account for vacancies, repairs and taxes.
  5. Guaranteeing the loan. See financing; the Tax Court treats a personal guaranty as a prohibited extension of credit.
  6. Buying from yourself or selling to family. Moving a property you already own into the IRA, or selling the IRA's property to your parents or children, is a prohibited sale (4975(c)(1)(A)). IRA contributions can't be made in property anyway.
  7. Paying yourself. A management fee, a commission or a salary from the IRA or its LLC. That was the violation in Ellis.
  8. Pledging the account. Using the IRA as security for a loan is itself prohibited (Publication 590-A).

What happens if you break a rule

Effect on the account
IRA (traditional or Roth)
Stops being an IRA as of January 1 of the year of the transaction (408(e)(2))
Solo 401(k)
Plan isn’t automatically disqualified
Tax
IRA (traditional or Roth)
Entire account treated as distributed at its fair market value on January 1; taxable to the extent it exceeds basis
Solo 401(k)
Excise tax of 15% of the amount involved for each year, plus 100% if not corrected, paid by the disqualified person on Form 5330
If under 59 and a half
IRA (traditional or Roth)
Plus the 10% additional tax on early distributions unless an exception applies
Solo 401(k)
Not a distribution, so no 10% tax from the excise itself
Penalties seen in the cases
IRA (traditional or Roth)
Accuracy-related penalties on the unreported income were upheld in Ellis and McNulty
Solo 401(k)
Rollins: excise taxes, plus additions to tax for not filing Form 5330

Sources: 26 U.S.C. 408(e)(2); Publication 590-A; 26 U.S.C. 4975(a), (b) and (c)(3); IRS, tax on prohibited transactions; Form 5330 instructions; IRS Topic 558. An IRA owner who triggers 408(e)(2) isn't also charged the excise tax (4975(c)(3)). Only the account involved in the transaction is affected; other IRAs you own aren't.

A prohibited transaction can also continue. In Peek, the Tax Court treated guaranties that stayed in place for years as a continuing prohibited transaction, so the accounts couldn't be IRAs in the later years in which the IRS assessed tax (Peek v. Commissioner, 140 T.C. 216 (2013)).


The Court Cases That Drew the Lines

These are the cases most often cited on self-directed accounts. We read each one in the opinion or in an IRS document describing it; none involves a physician, but each one maps to a mistake a physician could make with a rental.

Swanson v. Commissioner, 106 T.C. 76 (1996)
What happened
IRA bought all the new stock of a company its owner set up
Holding
Issuing the stock wasn’t prohibited: the company wasn’t yet a disqualified person
The real estate lesson
Basis for an IRA-owned LLC; says nothing about what you do with it afterward
Rollins v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2004-260
What happened
A plan trustee lent his company’s 401(k) money to businesses he partly owned (each under 50%)
Holding
Prohibited use of plan assets for his benefit, even though no borrower was a disqualified person
The real estate lesson
Staying under 50% ownership of a tenant or partner doesn’t make a deal safe
Peek v. Commissioner, 140 T.C. 216 (2013)
What happened
IRAs bought a company; the owners personally guaranteed a loan to the company
Holding
Each guaranty was an indirect extension of credit; the accounts stopped being IRAs
The real estate lesson
No personal guarantee on an IRA property loan
Thiessen v. Commissioner, 146 T.C. 100 (2016)
What happened
Rollover IRAs bought a company, which bought a business’s assets; the owners guaranteed the loan used for the purchase
Holding
Prohibited; the accounts were treated as distributed, and the six-year assessment period applied
The real estate lesson
Same rule; the IRS can reach back years
Ellis v. Commissioner, 787 F.3d 1213 (8th Cir. 2015)
What happened
IRA owned 98% of an LLC that ran a used-car business and paid the owner a salary
Holding
The wages were a prohibited transfer of the IRA’s income and assets; whole IRA deemed distributed
The real estate lesson
Don’t pay yourself to manage the IRA’s property
In re Kellerman, 538 B.R. 776 (E.D. Ark. 2015)
What happened
Self-directed IRA bought land jointly with a partnership the owners held 50/50, for development
Holding
Prohibited; the IRA lost its status as of January 1, 2007 and its bankruptcy exemption
The real estate lesson
Don’t co-invest the IRA with yourself or your companies
McNulty v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. No. 10 (2021)
What happened
IRA-owned LLCs bought coins; the owner kept them at home
Holding
Taxable distributions plus accuracy-related penalties
The real estate lesson
The LLC’s assets aren’t yours to hold or use

Sources: IRS FSA 200128011 (Swanson); IRS Chief Counsel memorandum 202504014 (Rollins); Peek; Thiessen; Ellis; Kellerman v. Rice; McNulty. Swanson's and Rollins's holdings are described from IRS documents and later opinions that discuss them; we did not find the original opinions on a court or government site.


Financing: Non-Recourse Loans Only

An IRA or solo 401(k) can borrow to buy property, but only on its own credit. The usual reading, which the Tax Court has applied, is that a guaranty, co-signature or pledge of your own assets is an indirect extension of credit between you and the account (4975(c)(1)(B); Peek; Thiessen). So the loan has to be non-recourse: if it goes unpaid, the lender can take the property and nothing else. The borrower is the IRA (through the custodian) or the IRA's LLC, and the account makes every payment.

  • Who lends. Not every lender makes non-recourse loans to retirement accounts. We found no authoritative source for typical down payments, rates or terms, so we don't quote any; get written terms from several lenders and compare them with a conventional loan.
  • No loan from you or your family. A loan from you, your spouse, parents or children to the account is itself a prohibited transaction (4975(c)(1)(B)), and so is a loan from the IRA to any of them (Publication 590-A). An IRA has no participant-loan feature at all.
  • Seller financing from an unrelated seller works the same way as a bank loan: non-recourse, no guaranty.
  • The tax cost. In an IRA, the loan makes part of the income taxable as unrelated debt-financed income, covered next. In a solo 401(k), that tax generally doesn't apply to real estate debt.

UBIT and Unrelated Debt-Financed Income

IRAs and qualified plans are tax-exempt, but sections 511 to 514 tax them on unrelated business taxable income (UBTI), at trust rates (26 U.S.C. 511(b); IRS Publication 598). For real estate, three rules matter.

  1. Rent from real property is excluded, along with gains on selling property that isn't inventory (512(b)(3) and (b)(5)). An all-cash rental in an IRA generally owes nothing. The exclusion doesn't cover rent that depends on the tenant's income or profits, rent from personal property above set thresholds, or payments where services are provided to the occupant, such as hotel rooms and similar lodging (Publication 598). A furnished short-term rental run like a hotel can produce taxable income even with no loan.
  2. Debt-financed income is not excluded. When property is bought with borrowed money ("acquisition indebtedness"), a share of its income and of its deductions, and a share of any gain on sale, is unrelated debt-financed income (26 U.S.C. 514).
  3. Qualified plans get an exception for real property. Section 514(c)(9) takes debt a qualified trust, such as a solo 401(k), incurs to buy or improve real property out of acquisition indebtedness, if conditions are met (see the solo 401(k) route). IRAs are not on the list of organizations it covers.

The debt-financed formula

The taxable share for a year is the average acquisition indebtedness divided by the average adjusted basis, capped at 100% (514(a)(1); 26 CFR 1.514(a)-1):

  • Average acquisition indebtedness is the principal outstanding on the first day of each calendar month the account holds the property during the year, added up and divided by the number of months (514(c)(7); Reg. 1.514(a)-1).
  • Average adjusted basis is the average of the property's adjusted basis on the first and the last day the account holds it during the year. Basis is reduced by all the depreciation, not just the part deducted (Reg. 1.514(a)-1; Form 990-T instructions).
  • That share applies to the gross rent and to the deductions directly connected with the property: operating expenses, interest and depreciation (514(a)(2)). Depreciation must be straight-line (514(a)(3)), and bonus depreciation isn't allowed for this purpose (T.D. 9283).
  • On a sale, the numerator becomes the highest acquisition indebtedness during the 12 months ending with the sale, and that share of the gain is taxable (514(a)(1); Publication 598). Paying the loan off more than 12 months before selling takes the gain out of the tax; paying it off at closing doesn't.

The account then subtracts a $1,000 specific deduction (512(b)(12)). A net loss in one year carries forward and can offset up to 80% of a later year's unrelated income from the same activity (Form 990-T instructions).

Trust tax rates

An IRA's unrelated income is taxed at the rates for trusts and estates, which are compressed: the 37% bracket starts at $16,000 of taxable income in 2026, against $768,700 for a married couple filing jointly (Rev. Proc. 2025-32; Form 990-T instructions). Net capital gain is taxed at 0%, 15% and 20% using the trust thresholds on Schedule D (Form 1041), and the part of a real estate gain caused by depreciation can be taxed at up to 25% as unrecaptured section 1250 gain (IRS Topic 409).

10%
2026
Up to $3,300
2027
Up to $3,400
24%
2026
$3,300 to $11,700
2027
$3,400 to $12,100
35%
2026
$11,700 to $16,000
2027
$12,100 to $16,500
37%
2026
Over $16,000
2027
Over $16,500
0% capital gain rate
2026
Up to $3,300
2027
Up to $3,400
15% capital gain rate
2026
Up to $16,250
2027
Up to $16,750
20% capital gain rate
2026
Over $16,250
2027
Over $16,750

Sources: Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (2026) and Rev. Proc. 2026-35 (2027; IR-2026-133), estates and trusts tables; 26 U.S.C. 1(e) and (h).

Form 990-T: the IRA files, the IRA pays

  • The tax is the account's, not yours. The IRA's trustee or custodian must file Form 990-T when the account has $1,000 or more of gross income from unrelated business; each IRA is a separate trust for this purpose (Form 990-T instructions). For debt-financed property, the gross income is the debt-financed share of the gross rent, so a leveraged rental usually crosses the filing threshold even in years it owes no tax. In our example it is $14,019 in year 1.
  • For IRAs and qualified plan trusts, the return is due on the 15th day of the 4th month after the year ends: April 15 for a calendar year, or October 15 with an extension (IRS due dates for Form 990-T).
  • Ask the custodian before you buy who prepares the 990-T, who signs it and what it costs; the law puts the filing on the trustee or custodian, but how custodians handle it in practice differs, and we found no single source describing it.
  • A Roth IRA owes the tax the same way; the Roth label doesn't exempt unrelated income.

The Solo 401(k) Route for Physicians With 1099 Income

A solo 401(k), which the IRS calls a one-participant 401(k), covers a business owner with no employees other than a spouse, or partners and their spouses (IRS). Physicians usually qualify through locums, consulting, expert witness or telehealth income, or a practice with no staff. If the business hires employees who meet the plan's eligibility rules, the plan must cover them and is no longer a one-participant plan. Our 1099 physician taxes guide covers the self-employment side, and our side income guide the ways physicians earn it.

2026 and 2027 limits

Employee deferral (shared across all your 401(k) and 403(b) plans)
2026
$24,500
2027
$25,500
Total additions per plan (deferral plus employer), excluding catch-ups
2026
$72,000
2027
$75,000
Catch-up, age 50 and over
2026
$8,000
2027
$8,500
Catch-up, ages 60 to 63
2026
$11,250
2027
$11,750
Compensation counted
2026
$360,000
2027
$375,000
IRA contribution (for comparison)
2026
$7,500
2027
$7,500

Sources: Notice 2025-67 (2026); Notice 2026-66 and IR-2026-136, November 12, 2026 (2027). For a self-employed physician, the employer contribution is 20% of net self-employment earnings after the deduction for half of self-employment tax (Publication 560). Our contribution limits guide explains which limits stack.

The limits matter for real estate in a way people miss: an IRA can take only $7,500 a year of new money, so a property that needs a new roof can strain it, while a solo 401(k) can take up to $72,000 in 2026 if your self-employment income supports it.

Why a solo 401(k) is better for a mortgage: section 514(c)(9)

Debt that a qualified trust incurs to buy or improve real property isn't acquisition indebtedness, so the rent and gain stay out of UBTI, unless one of these is true (514(c)(9)(A) to (C); IRS training text on section 514):

  1. the price isn't a fixed amount set when the property is bought or the improvement completed;
  2. the amount or timing of any payment on the debt depends on the property's revenue, income or profits;
  3. the property is leased back to the seller or a person related to the seller;
  4. for a plan, the property is bought from, or later leased to, the employer, a 50% owner, an entity 50% owned by them, or a person related to any of them (a lease of no more than 25% of a building's leasable floor space on commercially reasonable terms is disregarded);
  5. the seller or one of those people provides the financing on terms that aren't commercially reasonable; or
  6. the property is held through a partnership that doesn't meet further allocation rules.

A plain purchase from an unrelated seller, financed by a bank on a fixed note, usually meets the test. Section 514(c)(9) only removes the debt-financed income tax. It doesn't relax the prohibited transaction rules, which apply to a solo 401(k) in full, and it doesn't cover income from an operating business or a hotel-type rental.

Checkbook solo 401(k), filings and loans

  • Trustee. Solo 401(k) documents can name the owner as trustee (how often providers do so is a matter of provider practice, not law), so the plan can hold title and a bank account in the plan's name without a custodian. That is the plan equivalent of a checkbook IRA, with the same responsibility for keeping every transaction at arm's length. Whether real estate is allowed depends on the plan document, which comes from the provider.
  • Form 5500-EZ. A one-participant plan must file Form 5500-EZ for any year its assets, added together with your other one-participant plans, are more than $250,000 at year-end, and for its final year. Late filing can cost $250 a day, up to $150,000 (IRS; Form 5500-EZ instructions). The property's value counts toward that threshold.
  • Participant loans. A 401(k) may lend you up to the lesser of $50,000 or 50% of your vested balance (or up to $10,000 if the plan allows), repaid over 5 years, or longer for a loan to buy your principal residence (IRS; IRS loan FAQs; 26 U.S.C. 72(p)). A loan that meets those rules is exempt from the prohibited transaction rules, owners included (4975(d)(1) and (f)(6)(B)(iii)). The money is then yours, so you could put it toward your own home. That is a personal loan, not a way to have the plan own a property you use: the plan buying a home or vacation property for you is still prohibited. IRAs can't make loans at all.
  • Moving IRA money in. You can roll a traditional IRA into a 401(k) if the plan accepts rollovers, which also helps a backdoor Roth. A Roth IRA can only go to another Roth IRA (IRS rollover chart).

Worked Example: A Leveraged Rental in an IRA vs. a Solo 401(k)

Assumptions

  • A single-family rental bought in January for $400,000, 20% of it land. Closing costs are left out.
  • The account pays $240,000 in cash and borrows $160,000 (40% of the price) on a non-recourse loan at 7% amortized over 25 years ($1,131 a month). The rate and loan size are assumptions, not lender terms.
  • Rent of $2,900 a month in year 1, rising 3% a year; operating costs (property tax, insurance, repairs, management, vacancy) at 35% of rent.
  • Straight-line depreciation of the building over 27.5 years with the mid-month convention.
  • Sold in December of year 10 at 3% a year of appreciation, less 6% selling costs; the loan is repaid from the proceeds.
  • Tax at the 2026 trust rates for every year, the $1,000 specific deduction, loss carryforwards limited to 80% of a year's income, and the whole gain at the 0%, 15% and 20% capital gain rates. The part of the gain caused by depreciation can be taxed at up to 25%, so the real sale figure can be somewhat higher. Calculations are ours, in the code behind this page.

Step 1: the taxable share each year

In year 1 the loan averages $158,892 and the property's basis averages $394,424, so 40.3% of the year's income and deductions is debt-financed. Rent of $34,800 minus $12,180 of operating costs, $11,122 of interest and $11,152 of depreciation leaves $346 of net income; 40.3% of it is $139, below the $1,000 specific deduction, so the IRA owes nothing. Each year the loan shrinks, but depreciation shrinks the basis too, so the share drifts up slightly, to 44.2% by year 10.

Chart: share of the rental's income taxed as debt-financed income

Self-directed IRASolo 401(k)
0%10%20%30%40%50%Year 1234567891044.2%IRA, year 100%Solo 401(k)
1
Average loan
$158,892
Average basis
$394,424
Debt-financed share
40.3%
Net rental income
$346
Taxable share of it
$139
UBIT owed by the IRA
$0
2
Average loan
$156,364
Average basis
$383,030
Debt-financed share
40.8%
Net rental income
$717
Taxable share of it
$293
UBIT owed by the IRA
$0
3
Average loan
$153,654
Average basis
$371,394
Debt-financed share
41.4%
Net rental income
$1,605
Taxable share of it
$664
UBIT owed by the IRA
$0
4
Average loan
$150,748
Average basis
$359,758
Debt-financed share
41.9%
Net rental income
$2,529
Taxable share of it
$1,060
UBIT owed by the IRA
$6
5
Average loan
$147,631
Average basis
$348,121
Debt-financed share
42.4%
Net rental income
$3,488
Taxable share of it
$1,479
UBIT owed by the IRA
$48
6
Average loan
$144,289
Average basis
$336,485
Debt-financed share
42.9%
Net rental income
$4,486
Taxable share of it
$1,924
UBIT owed by the IRA
$92
7
Average loan
$140,706
Average basis
$324,848
Debt-financed share
43.3%
Net rental income
$5,524
Taxable share of it
$2,393
UBIT owed by the IRA
$139
8
Average loan
$136,863
Average basis
$313,212
Debt-financed share
43.7%
Net rental income
$6,603
Taxable share of it
$2,885
UBIT owed by the IRA
$189
9
Average loan
$132,743
Average basis
$301,576
Debt-financed share
44.0%
Net rental income
$7,726
Taxable share of it
$3,401
UBIT owed by the IRA
$240
10
Average loan
$128,325
Average basis
$290,182
Debt-financed share
44.2%
Net rental income
$9,380
Taxable share of it
$4,148
UBIT owed by the IRA
$19,473 (includes the sale)

Computed from the assumptions above. The solo 401(k) column would be 0% and $0 in every year. Rent and depreciation in years 1 and 10 reflect a full year of rent and 11.5 months of depreciation.

Step 2: the sale

After 10 years the property sells for $537,567, or $505,313 after selling costs. Depreciation of $115,394 has cut the basis to $284,606, so the gain is $220,706. The highest loan balance in the last 12 months was $130,401, and the average basis in the sale year was $290,182, so 44.9% of the gain, $99,180, is debt-financed income.

Add that year's $4,148 of taxable rental income and subtract the $1,000 deduction, and the IRA has $102,328 of taxable income: $3,148 of ordinary income taxed at 10%, then the gain at 0% on the first $152, 15% up to $16,250 and 20% above. The tax for the year is $19,473, of which $19,158 comes from the sale.

Step 3: the result

UBIT on the rent
IRA with the loan
$1,029
IRA, all cash
$0
Solo 401(k) with the loan
$0
UBIT on the gain
IRA with the loan
$19,158
IRA, all cash
$0
Solo 401(k) with the loan
$0
Total UBIT
IRA with the loan
$20,187
IRA, all cash
$0
Solo 401(k) with the loan
$0
Form 990-T needed?
IRA with the loan
Yes, every year (gross debt-financed income over $1,000)
IRA, all cash
No, unless other unrelated income
Solo 401(k) with the loan
No, if 514(c)(9) is met
Why
IRA with the loan
Debt-financed income, 514(a)
IRA, all cash
Rent and gain excluded, 512(b)(3) and (5)
Solo 401(k) with the loan
Real property exception, 514(c)(9)

Computed from the assumptions above. The all-cash IRA needs the full purchase price in the account; the comparison is of tax, not of return.

Three things stand out. Year to year, depreciation and interest absorb most of the rent, so the IRA's yearly bill is small ($1,029 over ten years). The tax arrives at the sale, because the gain is large and the debt-financed share is set by the highest loan balance in the last year. And the share tracks the loan: the more the account borrows, the larger the bill.

Chart: total UBIT over the 10-year hold, by loan size

$0$10K$20K$30KNo loan (all cash)$025% loan ($100,000)$12,75340% loan ($160,000)$20,18750% loan ($200,000)$24,66560% loan ($240,000)$27,160

A solo 401(k) holding the same property with the same loan owes $0 at every loan size, if the section 514(c)(9) conditions are met.

None (all cash)
UBIT on the rent
$0
UBIT on the gain
$0
Total
$0
Solo 401(k)
$0
25% ($100,000)
UBIT on the rent
$1,158
UBIT on the gain
$11,595
Total
$12,753
Solo 401(k)
$0
40% ($160,000)
UBIT on the rent
$1,029
UBIT on the gain
$19,158
Total
$20,187
Solo 401(k)
$0
50% ($200,000)
UBIT on the rent
$589
UBIT on the gain
$24,076
Total
$24,665
Solo 401(k)
$0
60% ($240,000)
UBIT on the rent
$0
UBIT on the gain
$27,160
Total
$27,160
Solo 401(k)
$0

Same assumptions, changing only the loan. With larger loans the early years show losses; those carry forward and absorb later rental income, so nearly all the tax comes from the gain.

The tax is paid from the account, so it reduces what compounds for retirement. Two ways to shrink it in an IRA: borrow less, or pay the loan off more than 12 months before selling. Or hold a leveraged property in a solo 401(k) that meets section 514(c)(9). None of this changes the larger question of whether a rental is a better retirement investment than a diversified fund, which depends on rents, vacancies, repairs and prices nobody can promise.


Roth vs. Traditional, RMDs and Illiquidity

Depreciation and losses stay inside the account

The biggest tax advantage of owning rentals personally, depreciation that shelters rent and, for some, other income, is wasted inside a retirement account: the account is already tax-exempt, so depreciation only matters for the debt-financed share. Losses don't reach your return either. And a traditional IRA or 401(k) turns what would have been long-term capital gain into ordinary income when you withdraw it (Publication 590-B). Our real estate taxes guide explains what depreciation and real estate professional status can do outside a retirement account.

Roth or traditional

  • A Roth IRA has no required distributions during your life, and qualified withdrawals are tax-free, which suits a long-held, appreciating asset (IRS RMD FAQs). It still owes UBIT on debt-financed income, and the prohibited transaction rules apply in full.
  • A traditional IRA or 401(k) requires distributions starting at 73, or 75 for people born in 1960 or later (IRS; 2024 final regulations). Since 2024, designated Roth accounts in a 401(k) no longer have lifetime required distributions (IRS RMD comparison chart).

A house can't be sold one slice at a time

  • Required distributions need cash or a deed. If most of a traditional IRA is one property, keep enough cash or liquid assets in it, or in other IRAs, to cover RMDs. The alternative is distributing the property, or an interest in it, in kind, which is taxed on its fair market value and reported on Form 1099-R (Form 1099-R and 5498 instructions).
  • A value every year. The custodian reports the account's fair market value each year on Form 5498, with assets that have no readily available market value, real estate among them, flagged separately and valued as of December 31 (Form 5498 instructions, boxes 15a and 15b). Expect to supply a valuation, which costs money.
  • Selling takes months, and a sale forced by an RMD, a vacancy or a large repair may come at a bad time.

Fees and Practical Costs

Each custodian and plan provider sets its own fees. We didn't find an independent source for typical amounts, so rather than quote one provider's numbers we list what to price. Get every item in writing.

  1. Account setup and annual fees at the custodian, and whether the annual fee rises with the account's value or the number of assets.
  2. Per-transaction fees: purchase and sale processing, each bill paid, each rent deposit, wires, overnight document fees. On a custodian-held rental these recur every month.
  3. LLC costs for a checkbook structure: formation, the state's annual fee or report, a registered agent, an operating agreement drafted for an IRA owner, and a separate bank account.
  4. Solo 401(k) plan document and any annual administration fee; Form 5500-EZ preparation once assets pass $250,000.
  5. Form 990-T preparation every year a leveraged IRA rental has $1,000 or more of gross debt-financed income.
  6. Annual valuation for Form 5498, and an appraisal at purchase.
  7. Property costs that every rental has, paid from the account: management, insurance, repairs, property tax, vacancy, loan costs.
  8. Exit costs: selling costs, or a valuation and deed work to distribute the property.

Fraud Risk

The SEC, FINRA and the state securities regulators have warned for years that self-directed accounts attract fraud, because they can hold unregistered, hard-to-value investments and because promoters misstate what custodians do (SEC investor alert, Self-Directed IRAs and the Risk of Fraud; NASAA). The alert's main points for a physician being pitched a real estate deal:

  • A custodian doesn't evaluate the investment or the promoter, and its name on the paperwork isn't an endorsement.
  • Use extreme caution with an unsolicited offer that promotes using a self-directed IRA, and treat words like "risk-free" or "guaranteed profit" as hallmarks of fraud.
  • Custodians may simply report the purchase price or a figure the promoter supplies as the account's value; verify it with an independent valuation or the property's tax assessment records.
  • Confirm the custodian is legitimate (fraudsters pose as custodians), and get a second opinion from an unbiased professional or an attorney before investing.

Promoters sometimes market a "self-directed IRA" as if the account type were the opportunity. The account is only a wrapper; the property, the price and the tenant are the investment, and each needs the same diligence you would give a property bought with your own money. Our real estate investing review covers how to vet platforms and sponsors.


The Alternatives

What it is
Self-directed IRA or solo 401(k) rental
The account owns the property
Rental owned personally
You own it, often through an LLC
REIT fund in a regular IRA or 401(k)
Shares of many properties
Cash balance plan
A pension that lets you contribute more pre-tax
Depreciation and losses
Self-directed IRA or solo 401(k) rental
Wasted, except to reduce debt-financed income
Rental owned personally
Deductible, subject to the passive loss rules
REIT fund in a regular IRA or 401(k)
Not yours to deduct
Cash balance plan
Not applicable
Leverage
Self-directed IRA or solo 401(k) rental
Non-recourse only; UBIT in an IRA
Rental owned personally
Any loan you qualify for
REIT fund in a regular IRA or 401(k)
Inside the REITs
Cash balance plan
Not what the plan is for; see our guide
Personal use or family tenants
Self-directed IRA or solo 401(k) rental
Never
Rental owned personally
Allowed (with tax consequences)
REIT fund in a regular IRA or 401(k)
Not applicable
Cash balance plan
Prohibited, same rules
Effort and cost
Self-directed IRA or solo 401(k) rental
High
Rental owned personally
High
REIT fund in a regular IRA or 401(k)
Low
Cash balance plan
Actuary and annual filings
Liquidity
Self-directed IRA or solo 401(k) rental
Low
Rental owned personally
Low
REIT fund in a regular IRA or 401(k)
Daily
Cash balance plan
At plan termination or separation

Summary of the rules covered above; REIT dividends in a retirement account are generally not unrelated business income (Publication 598 excludes dividends), but private real estate funds organized as partnerships that borrow can pass debt-financed income through to an IRA (512(c)).

  • Owning personally. Depreciation, interest and expenses offset rent; with real estate professional status or short-term rental rules, losses can offset other income. Our real estate taxes guide covers when.
  • REITs and real estate funds. A low-cost REIT index fund in a 401(k), IRA or backdoor Roth gets real estate exposure with no prohibited transaction risk, no custodian fees and no 990-T. Our real estate investing guide explains why REIT dividends fit retirement accounts.
  • A cash balance plan is the tool for putting more pre-tax money away once a solo 401(k) is full; see our cash balance plan guide.

Who It Suits, and a Checklist

Can make sense

  • Physicians with a large rollover IRA or solo 401(k), real estate experience and a long horizon, who want a specific property and will never use it.
  • 1099 or practice-owner physicians who can use a solo 401(k) for a leveraged purchase and can keep contributing to cover costs.
  • A Roth account owner willing to buy for cash and hold for decades.

Usually doesn't

  • Anyone who wants to use the property, rent it to family, or do the work.
  • A small IRA where one property would be most of the account and fees a large share of the return.
  • Physicians in their 60s with traditional accounts, where RMDs will soon force a sale or an in-kind distribution.
  • Anyone who would benefit from depreciation and losses on their own return.

Before you buy

  1. Does the property have any connection to you, your spouse, parents, children, grandchildren, their spouses or your companies, as seller, tenant, lender, manager or co-owner?
  2. Is the loan non-recourse, with no guaranty or pledge from you?
  3. Does the account hold enough cash for vacancies, repairs, taxes and any 990-T, without you adding money outside the contribution limits?
  4. Would a solo 401(k) avoid the debt-financed income tax, and does its document allow real estate?
  5. Who prepares Form 990-T, Form 5500-EZ and the annual valuation, and what does each cost?
  6. How will you handle RMDs and the eventual sale or distribution?
  7. Has a CPA or ERISA attorney reviewed the structure?

Questions to ask a custodian or plan provider

  1. Do you hold real estate and LLC interests, and how do you title the property?
  2. What are your setup, annual, per-transaction and wire fees, and how are rent deposits and bills processed?
  3. Do you prepare or file Form 990-T, and what do you charge?
  4. What valuation do you need each year for Form 5498, and from whom?
  5. Which non-recourse lenders have you worked with?
  6. How do you handle in-kind distributions of real estate?
  7. What do you review before funding a purchase, and what don't you review? (Expect the answer that you don't vet the investment.)

If you want an adviser to review the plan, see our financial advisors for physicians review, and our asset protection guide for how retirement accounts and LLCs fit with liability planning.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I buy rental property with my IRA?

Yes. The law doesn't bar IRAs from owning real estate, but many IRA trustees don't offer it, so you need a self-directed IRA custodian that does. The property must be bought, financed, managed and paid for entirely by the IRA, at arm's length. You, your spouse, your parents and grandparents, your children and grandchildren and their spouses, and companies you control can't live in it, rent it, sell it to the IRA, buy it from the IRA, lend to it, guarantee its loan, or work on it. If the IRA uses a loan, part of the rent and of the gain on sale is taxable inside the IRA as unrelated debt-financed income.

Can I use a solo 401(k) to buy real estate?

Yes, if the plan document allows it, and for a leveraged purchase a solo 401(k) is usually the better account. A qualified plan's trust can borrow to buy real property without the debt-financed income tax an IRA pays, under section 514(c)(9), as long as the price is fixed, the loan terms don't depend on the property's income, and the property isn't bought from or leased to the employer, its owners or related people. The prohibited transaction rules apply the same way they do to an IRA. You need self-employment or business income to have a solo 401(k), such as locums, consulting or a practice with no employees other than a spouse.

Can I live in or vacation at a property my self-directed IRA owns?

No. Using IRA property yourself, or letting your spouse, parents, children or grandchildren use it, is a transfer of the account's assets for a disqualified person's benefit. The IRS lists buying property for personal use, present or future, with IRA funds as a prohibited transaction. A night at the beach house counts. If you want to retire into a property the IRA owns, it would have to be distributed to you first, which is taxable at its fair market value from a traditional IRA.

Can I manage or fix up a property owned by my IRA?

You can make decisions for it, such as approving a lease or choosing a contractor, and have the custodian or the IRA's LLC pay the bills. Doing the work yourself is riskier. Furnishing services between the IRA and a disqualified person is listed in section 4975(c)(1)(C), IRA contributions must be cash, and custodians and practitioners widely treat an owner's repairs, renovation labor or paid management as prohibited. We found no court case squarely on unpaid repairs, so treat it as a line not to cross. Hire unrelated contractors and a property manager, paid from the IRA.

Do I pay UBIT on real estate in an IRA?

Not on an all-cash rental: rent from real property and gain on its sale are excluded from unrelated business taxable income. With a loan, the debt-financed share of the net rent and of the gain is taxable, at trust tax rates that reach 37% above $16,000 of taxable income in 2026. The IRA, not you, owes the tax; the custodian files Form 990-T for the IRA once its gross unrelated income reaches $1,000, and there is a $1,000 specific deduction. Short-term rentals with hotel-type services aren't rent from real property at all, so their income can be taxable even without a loan.

Can I get a mortgage in a self-directed IRA?

Only a non-recourse loan: one where the lender can look only to the property, not to you. You can't personally guarantee it, co-sign it, or pledge other assets; the Tax Court has held that a personal guaranty of a loan to an IRA-owned company is a prohibited extension of credit (Peek, 2013; Thiessen, 2016), and using the IRA itself as security for a loan is also prohibited. Not every lender makes these loans, so compare written terms from several. The loan also makes part of the income taxable as unrelated debt-financed income.

Is a checkbook IRA legal?

No statute, regulation or IRS ruling authorizes the IRA-owned LLC ("checkbook IRA") structure, and none forbids it. It rests mainly on Swanson v. Commissioner (1996), where the Tax Court held that an IRA's purchase of stock in a newly formed company was not a prohibited transaction because the company wasn't yet a disqualified person. The cases since show where it fails: wages paid to the owner by the IRA's company (Ellis), personal guaranties (Peek), and taking personal possession of assets the LLC bought (McNulty). Use it only with careful records and advice.

What happens if I break the prohibited transaction rules with my IRA?

The account stops being an IRA as of January 1 of the year the transaction happened, and its whole value on that date is treated as distributed to you: ordinary income for a traditional IRA, plus the 10% additional tax if you're under 59 and a half and no exception applies. Courts have upheld accuracy-related penalties when the return didn't report it (Ellis, McNulty). In a solo 401(k), the plan doesn't lose its status automatically; instead you owe a 15% excise tax on the amount involved for each year, and 100% if it isn't corrected, reported on Form 5330.

Can my IRA rent a property to my practice or my children?

No. Your children, grandchildren, parents and their spouses are disqualified persons, and so is a practice or company 50% or more owned by you and other disqualified persons, so a lease between them and your IRA is a prohibited transaction. Siblings, cousins and friends aren't on the statutory list, but renting to them still risks being an indirect benefit to you. In a solo 401(k), leasing the property to the sponsoring employer or its owners also takes away the 514(c)(9) exemption from debt-financed income.

Is a self-directed IRA worth it for a physician?

For most physicians, no: the costs, the prohibited transaction rules, the illiquidity and the tax on leveraged income outweigh the benefit, and REIT funds in an ordinary IRA or real estate owned in a taxable account (where depreciation can help you) are simpler. It can make sense for someone with a large IRA or solo 401(k), real estate experience, no need to use or touch the property, and the patience to run every expense through the account. A solo 401(k) is usually the better vehicle if you plan to borrow.

Sources

  1. 26 U.S.C. 4975 (prohibited transactions, disqualified persons, family, excise taxes, loan exemption) and 26 U.S.C. 408 (IRA requirements, 408(e)(2)), Cornell LII.
  2. Publication 590-A and Publication 590-B; Retirement topics: prohibited transactions; Retirement topics: tax on prohibited transactions; Instructions for Form 5330; Topic 558, IRS.
  3. Retirement plan investments FAQs and Retirement plans FAQs regarding IRAs, IRS.
  4. 26 U.S.C. 511, 512 and 514, Cornell LII; 26 CFR 1.514(a)-1; T.D. 9283 (no bonus depreciation under 514(a)(3)).
  5. Publication 598, Tax on unrelated business income of exempt organizations; IRC 514, unrelated debt-financed income (IRS exempt organizations training text); Instructions for Form 990-T; Return due dates for Form 990-T (trusts), IRS.
  6. Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (2026 trust brackets and capital gain thresholds; joint brackets), Rev. Proc. 2026-35 and IR-2026-133 (2027), 26 U.S.C. 1, and Topic 409 (25% rate on unrecaptured section 1250 gain), IRS.
  7. Swanson v. Commissioner, 106 T.C. 76 (1996), as described in IRS Field Service Advice 200128011 and in Peek.
  8. Rollins v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2004-260, as described in IRS Chief Counsel memorandum 202504014.
  9. Peek v. Commissioner, 140 T.C. 216 (2013) and Thiessen v. Commissioner, 146 T.C. 100 (2016), CourtListener.
  10. Ellis v. Commissioner, 787 F.3d 1213 (8th Cir. 2015), GovInfo.
  11. Kellerman v. Rice (In re Kellerman), 538 B.R. 776 (E.D. Ark. 2015), Justia.
  12. McNulty v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. No. 10 (2021), opinion text (copy hosted by Groom Law Group).
  13. Investor alert: Self-directed IRAs and the risk of fraud, SEC Office of Investor Education and Advocacy, with NASAA and FINRA; NASAA.
  14. One-participant 401(k) plans, One-participant plans with more than $250,000, Instructions for Form 5500-EZ and Publication 560, IRS.
  15. Retirement topics: loans, Retirement plans FAQs regarding loans and 26 U.S.C. 72(p).
  16. Notice 2025-67 (2026 limits), Notice 2026-66 and IR-2026-136 (2027 limits), IRS.
  17. Required minimum distributions FAQs, RMD comparison chart and final RMD regulations (Federal Register, July 19, 2024); Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498; Rollover chart, IRS.

Rules, cases and limits checked November 13, 2026. Points marked as custodian practice or practitioner reading (owner labor, paying expenses personally, how custodians handle Form 990-T, checkbook plan trustees) don't come from a statute, regulation or court holding.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, legal or investment advice. The prohibited transaction rules turn on facts, and a mistake can make an entire IRA taxable. The worked example uses an assumed price, loan, rent, expenses, growth and holding period, holds the 2026 trust tax rates flat and simplifies the capital gain computation; it is an illustration, not a projection or tax advice. Consult a CPA and an attorney experienced with self-directed accounts before buying property in a retirement account. MedMoneyGuide has no affiliate or advertising relationships with the companies it covers.

Joshua Dunigan, DO

About the Author

Joshua Dunigan, DO | Family Medicine Resident & Founder

I'm a family medicine resident physician in Des Moines, Iowa (class of 2027). I founded MedMoneyGuide to give physicians specialty-specific financial guidance, with sources you can check.